Best of the web: Welcome to “Octlantis”

    by Best of the Web
    Wednesday, 20 September 2017 17:53 BST

A young girl gets an up-close look at an octopus as SeaWorld unveils their new Ocean Explorer section at SeaWorld in San Diego, California, U.S., May 31, 2017. REUTERS/Mike Blake

Discover all the top land and property rights stories from across the web

In his book “The Octopus, the Sea, and the Deep Origins of Consciousness”, philosopher Peter Godfrey-Smith asks whether we could ever truly understand how extraterrestrials think.

“If we met an alien whose intelligence derived through an entirely separate provenance from ours, would we recognize the sparkle in each other’s eyes?”, Godfrey-Smith writes.

In search of the answer, he dived deep below the ocean, where, he argues, cephalopods - octopuses and cuttlefish - are probably the closest we’ll ever get to an intelligent mind that has developed entirely distinctly from our own.

These sea-floor-dwellers have developed wholly different anatomies - with more neurons in their arms than in their central brain and three hearts. Yet, he explains, they recognize human faces, display human-like personalities - shyness, confidence, feistiness - and sometimes act in curiously human ways.

On one dive, Godfrey-Smith watched his dive partner, Matt, as “an octopus grabbed his hand and . . . Matt followed, as if he were being led across the sea floor by a very small eight-legged child.” Ten minutes later they arrived at the octopus’s den.

And, it turns out - not content with individual homes - octopuses also build cities.

In the Guardian, Philip Hoare describes “Octlantis”, a site at Jervis Bay, south of Sydney, where octopuses have been seen exhibiting complex social behavior: congregating, communicating and even evicting unwanted neighbours.

“Its aquatic architects have constructed walls from clam and scallop shells, the remains of their former meals... these piles “were further sculpted to create dens, making these octopuses true environmental engineers”, writes Hoare.

This is actually the second octo-city discovered, after another nearby site in Jervis Bay, found 50ft below the surface in 2009 and named Octopolis, where the cephalopods had established a kind of artificial reef: “an underwater island of safety in a dangerous area, a defense against predators such as sharks, seals and dolphins,” he writes.

While community seems to bring safety, we’re yet to fully understand the workings of the under-sea city. But Hoare says we know that the residents are engaged in near constant competition for the best dens, with more powerful and dastardly octopuses chasing the weak from their homes.

Understanding an alien mind may be a long way off but, if creatures here on earth are anything to go by, it’s a safe bet they’ll have a housing crisis of their own.

Discover more top stories from around the web this week. Have we missed anything? Tweet at @mjponsford or email


15 indigenous activists win prestigious Equator Prize

'I pray she's already dead': chaos as Mexico City block collapses after quake

Bolivian president Evo Morales backs Universal Citizenship in U.N. speech attacking U.S.

More than one-in-10 apartments in downtown Los Angeles is empty - but rent still costs $2,500 a month

Cameroon forest people: Land rights abuses threaten survival

In Hong Kong, shortage of land for housing remains a thorny issue

Australian 'Right to Farm' plan reviewed to ease conflict between farmers and urban dwellers



Rebuilding New York After 9/11: former deputy mayor rezoned 40% of the city to build the city’s 21st century mega-projects - read the interview in CityLab

Georgia’s highlanders unite against hydropower from Open Democracy

The Last of the Bushmen: the lessons we can learn from the bushmen of the Kalahari in iNews

The first English social housing in rural Oxfordshire: designed for “foxhunters, farmers and parsons” from Municipal Dreams

The politics of disability: The production of most of the world’s disability happens through colonial violence and occupation, in The New Inquiry



The British government is backing the wrong side in housing construction: The Times of London says the UK should make affordable housing an iron-clad guarantee, not an option for developers

Opinion: Nothing for Indigenous people in Canada to celebrate on 10th anniversary of UN rights declaration

Will Blockchain revolutionise global real estate next? asks Fast Company

What is a fair price for expropriated land? Some legal analysis of a Supreme Court case in The South African.

Land reform without property rights is mere hot air, says The Herald, South Africa

Related News

Sign up for our weekly newsletter